See all of our plumbing services.
Short answer
A sump pump fails when it matters most: spring melt and rain on ground still frozen underneath. The same storms cause power outages, so a pump on grid power alone is unprotected in exactly the conditions it exists for. Test before the season, and treat backup power as the question, not an accessory. Two things follow from that.
The pump needs testing on a schedule, not being trusted because it worked last year, since a failed float or seized impeller announces itself only under load. And the discharge route matters as much as the pump: a line that freezes or discharges too close to the foundation returns the same water to the same pit. Ask a quote what backup it includes, where the discharge terminates, and how the system is tested after installation.
Jobs this covers
- Sump pump repair
- Pump replacement
- Battery backup systems
- High-water alarms
- Check valve and discharge repair
- New sump basin and pump evaluation
Common problems and warning signs
- The pump hums but does not move water
- It runs constantly or cycles rapidly
- The float sticks
- Water returns through the discharge
- The basement floods during outages
- The pump is old or undersized
What service may include
The check valve stops water falling back. Work may include testing the pump and float, clearing the intake, replacing the pump or check valve, correcting the discharge route, adding an alarm or battery backup, and testing the system under load.
What affects the recommendation and price
A battery backup is a second pump. Basin size, lift height, discharge length, water volume, power reliability, check-valve condition, exterior freezing risk and whether drainage work is also needed affect design.
What is different around Burlington
Vermont towns with public sewer generally prohibit sump pumps discharging into the sanitary sewer, so the water has to go to grade, a storm drain where the town allows it, or a dry well. Where the discharge line crosses a yard, one that freezes in March sends the water straight back to the pit.
What a written quote should tell you
- Pump capacity against the actual water volume, not a generic size
- Where the discharge terminates, and whether it can run back toward the foundation or freeze shut
- Backup provision, battery or generator, and how long it would run
- Whether a high-water alarm is included, since a silent failure is the expensive one
- Check-valve condition and basin cleaning, which are common causes of a pump that runs but moves nothing
| Same storm causes | Which is why |
|---|---|
| Peak sump load | Testing before the season beats trusting last year's result |
| Power outages | Grid power alone is unprotected in exactly the conditions the pump exists for |
How to test a sump pump before you need it
A pump that has not run since last spring may not run this spring. This takes five minutes and is best done in early March, before the melt.
- Look in the pit. Clear any debris, gravel or silt from the pit. Confirm the float can move freely and is not resting against the wall of the pit or against the pump.
- Pour water in. Empty a bucket of water into the pit until the float rises. The pump should start on its own.
- Watch that it actually moves water. Confirm the level in the pit falls. A pump that runs without lowering the water has lost its impeller or is discharging into a blockage.
- Confirm it shuts off. The pump should stop cleanly when the float drops. A pump that keeps running with a dry pit will destroy itself.
- Check the discharge outside. Go outside and confirm water is leaving the discharge pipe, that it drains away from the foundation, and that the line is not frozen or blocked. A frozen discharge line is a common Vermont cause of a pump that appears to have failed.
- Test the backup. If there is a battery backup, unplug the primary pump and repeat the test. Then check the battery's age. Batteries are consumables with a three-to-five-year life, and a backup with a dead battery is not a backup.
Common questions
How often should a sump pump be tested?
Test it before wet seasons and after long idle periods by following the manufacturer’s method. A pump that behaves unusually should be serviced.
Can a sump pump stop every kind of basement flooding?
No. Surface water, sewer backups, foundation leaks and plumbing failures require different solutions.
What is a battery backup sump pump and is it worth it?
It is a second, DC-powered pump in the same pit with its own battery, which takes over when the primary pump fails or the power goes out. Its value depends entirely on what a wet basement costs you: for an unfinished Vermont basement with a floor drain and nothing stored on the floor, it is optional. For a finished basement, a basement mechanical room, or a house that loses power in most winter storms, it is the difference between an inconvenience and a claim. The batteries are consumables with a three-to-five-year life, and a backup with a dead battery is not a backup.
How do I know if my sump pump is about to fail?
Listen and count. A pump that has become noisier, that rattles or grinds, that runs and does not move water, or that cycles on and off rapidly is telling you something. Rapid cycling usually means either a failed check valve returning water to the pit or a float set too tight, and both shorten the pump's life if left. A pump that runs continuously without lowering the level has either lost its impeller or is being outrun: check the discharge line outside for ice or a blockage before assuming the pump is the problem, because a frozen discharge line is a common Vermont cause.
Can I replace a sump pump myself?
Yes. It is one of the more approachable replacements: unplug the old unit, disconnect the discharge union, lift it out, set the new one, reconnect and test by filling the pit with a bucket. Two details people skip and then regret: the check valve, which stops the discharged column of water from falling straight back into the pit and cycling the pump, and the weep hole that prevents an airlock. Anything that needs a new dedicated circuit, or a pit that has to be cut into a slab, is a different job.
What happens if the sump pump fails during a storm?
The basement takes on water at whatever rate the ground is delivering it, and the failure almost always happens at the worst moment because that is when the pump is working hardest. In Vermont the compounding factor is spring: snowmelt over still-frozen ground produces sustained high water tables instead of a short burst, so a marginal pump that coped with summer rain can run continuously for days and burn out. The two failure modes to plan for are the pump dying and the power going out, and a storm that causes one commonly causes the other.
How long does a sump pump last?
Roughly seven to ten years for a good pedestal or submersible unit, but run hours matter far more than calendar age. A pump in a wet Vermont basement that cycles year-round can be at end of life in four or five years, while one that runs a few weeks each spring can outlast the house's owner. Test it quarterly by pouring water into the pit, and test it in early March specifically, before the melt rather than during it.
Where can a sump pump legally discharge in Vermont?
Not into the sanitary sewer, in essentially every Vermont municipality with a public system: clean groundwater sent to a wastewater plant is a direct cause of overflows during wet weather, and ordinances prohibit it. Acceptable discharge is generally to grade away from the foundation, to a storm drain where the town permits it, or to a dry well. Discharging to a neighbouring property can create a civil problem regardless of what the ordinance says. Check with your town's wastewater or public works department, because the rule and the enforcement both come from them.
What is a typical sump pump warranty?
Pump warranties typically run 3 to 5 years on residential models, and the difference between a warrantied failure and a not-covered one often comes down to whether the pump ran dry or was overloaded: read what voids it before relying on the number printed on the box.
What is the most common mistake with a battery backup pump?
Installing one and never testing it until the power actually goes out during a storm. A backup battery degrades on its own timeline regardless of whether the pump has run, and the only way to know it will work is to test it, not to assume it will.